Skip to content
MLDEV
PT Request a proposal

Custom or off-the-shelf software?

There is no single right answer for every company. There is a right answer for the way yours works. This guide helps you find it.

Laptop showing sales charts and indicators in management software

The difference, in a few words

Off-the-shelf software: it is the same program for many companies. It gets you started quickly, but you are the one who has to adapt to it.

Custom software: it is built around the way your company works. It takes longer to get going, but it adapts to you and grows with the business.

When an off-the-shelf program is enough

It usually makes sense when:

  • Your processes are the same as most companies in your sector;
  • You need to start now and the initial budget is small;
  • All the information fits in one program;
  • You don’t need to connect several systems;
  • The program’s features are enough, with no workarounds.

If that is your case, we tell you so in the initial assessment. It makes no sense to build from scratch what already exists and works.

When custom software pays off

It usually makes sense when:

  • Your work has specific steps and off-the-shelf software forces workarounds;
  • Information is spread across Excel sheets, emails and several programs;
  • You need to connect your ERP, invoicing, online shop or other systems;
  • You pay licences for modules you don’t use, or exactly what you need is missing;
  • You want the system to grow with the business, starting with one part and adding others.

Side-by-side comparison

SituationOff-the-shelfCustom
ProcessesThe same as mostSpecific to your company
StartImmediateIn phases, with deliveries you review
InformationIn a single programBrings together what is now scattered
IntegrationsWhatever the program includesWhatever your business needs
EvolutionDepends on the vendorKeeps pace with your business

Questions to ask before you decide

Answer these questions with your team:

  • Which tasks do we do by hand every day, in Excel or by email?
  • Where do information or time get lost between people and departments?
  • Which programs do we use today and which need to talk to each other?
  • If the off-the-shelf program doesn’t do X, can we work without X?
  • What do we want the system to do two or three years from now?

With these answers, the conversation with any vendor is shorter and the proposal more accurate.

How MLDEV helps you decide

In the initial assessment, which is free, we look at how you work and tell you frankly whether custom software, an off-the-shelf program or a mix of the two makes sense: for example, keeping your invoicing program and connecting it to a system built for the rest of your work. See what we do in Business Management Software.

Still unsure about your case?

Tell us what you need. The proposal is free and with no obligation.